VS
Edgewonk vs TradingDiary Pro: which trading journal should you choose?
Quick verdict
Edgewonk is best for discretionary traders working on discipline, rules and trading psychology. TradingDiary Pro is best for traders who would rather buy software once than pay a subscription.
TradingDiary Pro is the cheaper paid option.
Pick Edgewonk
Best for: Discretionary traders working on discipline, rules and trading psychology.
- Strongest discipline and rule tracking we have seen (Tiltmeter)
- Automatic weekly Edge Finder report
- One price for every feature, about $16 a month
Pick TradingDiary Pro
Best for: Traders who would rather buy software once than pay a subscription.
- No subscription: pay once and keep using it
- Covers stocks, options, futures and forex
- Long-established product (on sale since 2009)
Side-by-side comparison
| Edgewonk | TradingDiary Pro | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Discretionary traders working on discipline, rules and trading psychology | Traders who would rather buy software once than pay a subscription |
| Price | $197/yr (about $16/mo), all features | $149 one-time · optional $49/yr upgrades |
| Free plan | No | No |
| Trial / refund | 14-day money-back guarantee | None listed |
| Markets | Stocks, Options, Futures, Forex, Crypto | Stocks, Options, Futures, Forex |
| Broker coverage | Automated imports (see supported brokers) | Not confirmed |
| Broker auto-sync | Yes (automated imports) | Not confirmed |
| AI insights | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| Trade replay | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| Backtesting | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| Mentor / sharing | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| Psychology & rule tracking | Yes (Tiltmeter, Edge Finder) | Not confirmed |
| Options tools | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| Try Edgewonk → | Try TradingDiary Pro → |
Prices and features checked against each vendor's official site. "Not confirmed" means we could not verify it, not that it is missing.
Pricing compared
Edgewonk: $197/yr (about $16/mo), all features. TradingDiary Pro: $149 one-time · optional $49/yr upgrades. Edgewonk offers 14-day money-back guarantee.
Who should skip each
- Edgewonk: You want to pay month to month, or you need trade replay.
- TradingDiary Pro: You want AI insights, trade replay or a mobile app, which its website does not list.